Jdi na obsah Jdi na menu
 


Is captain Smith responsible for the great loss of life with the sinking of the Titanic.

 Captain Smith is responsible for the great loss of life with the sinking of the Titanic, how far do you agree with this statement?

 

                The Titanic was on one of the most luxurious ship ever built and was supposed to be unsinkable, but the exact opposite came true and the bad luck is not here to blame. Building the Titanic was finished in 1912 and in the same year this “Dream Ship” set off on its first voyage, which enrolled to the history as one of the biggest catastrophes ever.  Everybody knows a lot of stories about passengers, who died or conversely survived, but not many people know that bad luck was not the main reason why the Titanic hit the iceberg, however one of the reasons of this catastrophe was the Captain Smith himself. At first in this essay, I am going to explore reasons why the Titanic even hit the iceberg and later, I will be analysing reasons, why so many people died.

One of the main reasons why this catastrophe took place, were bad priorities of the crew and mainly of the captain. Despite the fact Captain Smith received several warnings about icebergs[1], he continued travelling at the top speed in the moonless and windless night just to beat the record and to reach the coast of New York earlier in order to get the blue ribbon. Generally, his selfish behaviour cost lives more than 1500 people.

                However, there are other aspects, which influenced this catastrophe. Another person responsible for crashing into an iceberg is Frederic Fleet –member of the crew–, who was on the lookout in the fatal night. There was no moonlight in the night on the 14th April, so there was almost no visibility and in addition there also was no wind, consequently the waves did not break over the icebergs, so it was much harder to see them.  Despite all these facts Fleet did not ask for binoculars and in addition, he was not even paying more attention, when it was still getting colder and colder, so he saw the iceberg late. We know this fact from Charles Lightoller’s testimony during the British inquiry. Because the crew was warn late, the ship had not enough time to change its direction or turn around and for this reason the Titanic hit the iceberg at 11:40 pm by its side.

                Finally, the last person to be blamed for hitting the iceberg is Jack Philips, wireless operator of the Titanic. He did not take seriously warnings, which the other ships –notably Californian[2]– were sending and on the contrary his priority was just dealing with passenger’s messages.  Besides, he did not give a very last urgent warning to the captain. Finally, he was rude to the Californian wireless and because of that, they switched their radio off and therefore, the Titanic was not able to send them a SOS message, when they were already sinking.

Although the Titanic hit the iceberg, there still was a possibility to at least save the passengers, but because of underestimated preparation, it did not happen. The very first people responsible for the great loss of lives on the sinking ship were Bruce Ismay and Alexander Carlisle – one of the owners of White Star Line and a designer–. They spent just about five minutes discussing the lifeboats and moreover, they decided to reduce the number of them, because they did not want the first class deck to be full of lifeboats as they also thought the ship was unsinkable. They reduced the number of lifeboats to twenty, although the Titanic needed at least sixteen times more of the boats to carry all the passengers in the time of need.  The reducing was the reason why many people did not find place in them during the evacuation. The worse thing is that some people could prevent this disaster, but their decision let the Titanic pass with not enough lifeboats. It was a British inspection, named Board of trade, which checked the Titanic before its voyage and owing to an old law about number of lifeboats, they agreed on twenty of them, which led to the great loss of life. Furthermore, Ismay and Carlisle decided to make the watertight compartments smaller in order to have more space for passenger’s luggage and thus the Titanic was not able to float, when they were flooded. For this reason, Titanic sank very quickly and there was no chance for Carpathia or some other ship to save the passengers, who were not in the lifeboats.

                The passengers could be rescued if the Titanic was able to float even though its chamber were flooded, but it did not happen, because in the five of them was already water and the ship could float only with water in four of them. This is a fault of Harland and Wolf company, which was building the Titanic. They decided to use one of the cheapest rivets[3] and as a result the rivets broke during the collision and the water got into the chambers. It is proven that if the steel rivets were used for every section of the ship, it could withstand more force. Also they use very thin plates, which just could not stand the strain of the iceberg and the latest test showed that it could be better for the Titanic to hit the iceberg straight by its fore. These are the reasons why the Titanic sank so quickly with no chance for Carpathia to get to the sinking ship on time to save more than 1,500 on board.

                It is natural that such a large catastrophe is followed by a lot of panic and confusion, but the biggest mistake on the sinking Titanic was a confusion of the crew. There was more than an hour delay in evacuation of the passengers, because not even the crew actually knew if the ship is really sinking. The passengers and also the crew thought it is just a drill or even some kind of joke, so they rather stayed inside the ship instead of standing on the cold deck. When it finally got to the filling and launching the lifeboats, the crew totally failed. Mostly only the first class passengers were allowed to the lifeboats and in addition, one of the member of the crew said that only women and children are allowed to be launched in the lifeboats, but the true is that the captain said:”Women and children first.” Furthermore, the crew was not able to properly launch the lifeboats, because they thought they were not enough strong to carry 65 people, therefore the boats were launched half-empty. However, the boats were tested with 70 men in them. Moreover, one of the lifeboats floated into the sea upside down and it could not be used anymore. This confusion could be prevent if the Captain Smith would not cancelled the prepared drill of filling the lifeboats in order to allow people to go to church. The last failure of the crew was when the saved members in the lifeboats were afraid of possible vortex after the Titanic sank, so they did not return for the people in the cold water.

                In conclusion, my opinion is that Captain Smith is definitely to be blamed for hitting the iceberg and just slightly for the loss of lives, however he is not the only one. As I mentioned, there are people such as Fredric Fleet and Jack Philips, which we can blame for their selfish behaviour, distraction, rudeness and bad priorities. In addition, there are lot of natural aspects why the Titanic hit the iceberg like no wind, no moonlight, el Niño effect etcetera, which can be classified just as a bad luck. Although Captain Smith is responsible for the collision, he is not responsible for a great loss of lives. There are people such as Bruce Ismay, Alexander Carlisle, Board of trade, Harland and Wolf or even the crew to be blamed. Instead of being too ambitious and caring just about their outstanding reputation, great appearance of the ship and in the main about money, they should better prepared the whole Titanic, including the ship itself and also the crew and the passengers to possibility of emergency situations. All in all, the Titanic catastrophe is an important and sad example in our history how the bad priorities and bad character trades of people can cause a disaster and I am sure that the people should not forget about it and they should learn from their mistakes and never let something like this happen again.  

Bibliography

British Wreck commissioner’s inquiry. Testimony from Charles Lightoller, Published on 20th May 1912

Cheap rivets blamed for massive loss of life as Titanic sank, article by D. Usborne , Published in the NY on 16th April 1912

The Washington times, Published on 2nd May 1912

Documentary film – the unsinkable Titanic

 

 

 

 

(1 505 words)

                 

               



[1] Iceberg-large piece of freshwater ice

[2] Californian – the ship nearest to the Titanic

[3] Rivet-is a permanent mechanical fastener

 

Komentáře

Přidat komentář

Přehled komentářů

lilla åland kopia

lilla åland kopia,27. 2. 2021 2:58


Wow that was odd. I just wrote an really long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn't appear. Grrrr... well I'm not writing all that over again. Regardless, just wanted to say fantastic blog! lilla åland kopia verdi.wommmewt.com/travels/lilla-land-kopia.php

офисные перегородки в минске

Ruslanvqo,26. 2. 2021 17:22

Привет господа!
Производим на заказ и устанавливаем стеклянные перегородки в квартиру и в офис по индивидуальным размерам. Мы постоянно следим за современными тенденциями и фурнитурой для стеклянных конструкций, и всегда готовы предложить вам различные решения для создания стильного интерьера в любом ценовом диапазоне. Межкомнатные стеклянные перегородки чаще всего служат для зонирования пространства.
Более подробная информация размещена https://drive.google.com/file/d/13CAPanRKgpkKCcaHzI0EiaMtWM0saPJO/view?usp=sharing

перегородки в квартиру

Ruslanyxu,26. 2. 2021 13:00

Доброго времени суток товарищи!
Предлагаем Вашему вниманию изделия из стекла для дома и офиса. Наша организация работает 10 лет на рынке этой продукции в Беларуси. Изготовим для вас и установим душевую кабину из стекла на заказ. Профессиональные замерщики и монтажники. Мы используем различные типы материалов и фурнитуры для создания душевых кабин и душевых перегородок любого дизайна и конструкции, устанавливаем на поддоны или без поддонов. У нас вы сможете заказать стекло для душевой кабины по индивидуальным размерам и проекту. Выполним доставку изделия и его монтаж.
Более подробная информация размещена https://drive.google.com/file/d/13CAPanRKgpkKCcaHzI0EiaMtWM0saPJO/view?usp=sharing

matusalem gran reserva

matusalem gran reserva,25. 2. 2021 3:47


Just wish to say your article is as amazing. The clarity in your post is simply cool and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission allow me to grab your RSS feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable work. matusalem gran reserva verdi.wommmewt.com/news/matusalem-gran-reserva.php

platt och locktång

platt och locktång,24. 2. 2021 22:48


Why viewers still use to read news papers when in this technological world the whole thing is existing on web? platt och locktång glosi.prizezwom.com/travels/platt-och-locktng.php

lernberger stafsing kicks

lernberger stafsing kicks,24. 2. 2021 16:16


Hi there to every one, it's in fact a nice for me to go to see this site, it includes useful Information. lernberger stafsing kicks mings.sewomenpriz.com/music/lernberger-stafsing-kicks.php

vad är en mediabox

vad är en mediabox,24. 2. 2021 4:56


Thanks for the good writeup. It if truth be told was a leisure account it. Glance complicated to more introduced agreeable from you! By the way, how could we communicate? vad är en mediabox speln.wommmewt.com/news/vad-aer-en-mediabox.php

pevaryl mot svamp

pevaryl mot svamp,24. 2. 2021 2:07


wonderful points altogether, you just gained a new reader. What might you suggest about your submit that you just made some days ago? Any sure? pevaryl mot svamp drear.prizezwom.com/for-men/pevaryl-mot-svamp.php

ta bort ärrvävnad

ta bort ärrvävnad,23. 2. 2021 14:47


I'm gone to tell my little brother, that he should also pay a quick visit this webpage on regular basis to obtain updated from hottest reports. ta bort ärrvävnad reend.wommmewt.com/beauty/ta-bort-aerrvaevnad.php

köpa guess väska

köpa guess väska,23. 2. 2021 4:51


Hey there exceptional website! Does running a blog such as this take a lot of work? I have no expertise in programming but I had been hoping to start my own blog in the near future. Anyhow, if you have any suggestions or techniques for new blog owners please share. I understand this is off subject however I just wanted to ask. Thanks! köpa guess väska unmil.prizezwom.com/news/koepa-guess-vaeska.php

när kan man tidigast göra gravtest

när kan man tidigast göra gravtest,23. 2. 2021 3:23


Wow, fantastic blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make running a blog look easy. The full look of your website is great, let alone the content material!
när kan man tidigast göra gravtest ibre.wommmewt.com/beauty/naer-kan-man-tidigast-goera-gravtest.php

termobyxor herr rea

termobyxor herr rea,22. 2. 2021 3:19


Thanks for finally talking about > < Loved it! termobyxor herr rea visri.wommmewt.com/delicious-dishes/termobyxor-herr-rea.php

Зарабатывай на Avito в 2021 году . Скидка 75% на онлайн-курс!

Avito,21. 2. 2021 20:40

Продвигайте свой бизнес на Авито. Как эффективнее это делать в 2021 году узнайте на онлайн-курсе.
Спешите, сейчас скидка 75%! Зайди по короткой ссылке: https://clck.ru/TPD5D и начни зарабатывать больше!

exuviance acne pads

exuviance acne pads,21. 2. 2021 15:59


Sweet blog! I found it while searching on Yahoo News. Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News? I've been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! Thank you exuviance acne pads sewomenpriz.com/beautiful-things/exuviance-acne-pads.php

georg jensen rea

georg jensen rea,21. 2. 2021 10:50


Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to mention that I have truly loved browsing your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing in your feed and I hope you write once more soon! georg jensen rea saujo.prizezwom.com/music/georg-jensen-rea.php

silk epil ansikte

silk epil ansikte,21. 2. 2021 5:03


Very descriptive blog, I loved that a lot. Will there be a part 2? silk epil ansikte plani.wommmewt.com/beauty/silk-epil-ansikte.php

brun med spruta

brun med spruta,20. 2. 2021 18:46


At this time I am going to do my breakfast, after having my breakfast coming yet again to read additional news. brun med spruta avam.wommmewt.com/sport/brun-med-spruta.php

daily microfoliant recension

daily microfoliant recension,20. 2. 2021 16:28


Good day! I could have sworn I've visited this web site before but after going through some of the articles I realized it's new to me. Regardless, I'm definitely delighted I stumbled upon it and I'll be bookmarking it and checking back frequently! daily microfoliant recension flatm.prizezwom.com/advice-girlfriends/daily-microfoliant-recension.php

ont i nageln

ont i nageln,20. 2. 2021 8:42


I absolutely love your blog and find a lot of your post's to be exactly what I'm looking for. Does one offer guest writers to write content in your case? I wouldn't mind publishing a post or elaborating on many of the subjects you write concerning here. Again, awesome weblog! ont i nageln mings.sewomenpriz.com/useful-tips/ont-i-nageln.php

få bort frissigt hår hemma

få bort frissigt hår hemma,19. 2. 2021 22:30


Great article. få bort frissigt hår hemma avthe.prizezwom.com/beautiful-things/f-bort-frissigt-hr-hemma.php